Dog Food Comparable To Kirkland

This page contains affiliate links. We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn More

Kirkland Dog Food is a private-label brand that is only available in the large retail store, Costco. It is advertised as a “Super Premium” dog food and comes at a very affordable price. But just how good is it? Let’s take a deeper look into this brand and some of its top recipes.

What Dog Food Brands Is Kirkland Most Comparable To?

So what dog food brands is Kirkland most comparable to?

Costco Kirkland Signature Adult Formula with Chicken, Rice and Vegetable greatly overlaps with these brands and formulations.

  • Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula™ Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe. The first four ingredients are identical in both formulations. However, Blue Buffalo takes most of its omega-3 fatty acids and fiber from flaxseeds and peas, which are listed higher in the ingredient list compared to Kirkland formulation.
  • Diamond Naturals All Life Stages Dog Chicken & Rice Formula. Diamond Naturals All Life Stages Dog Chicken & Rice Formula. Both formulations are highly similar except that Diamond Naturals contains extra carbs in the form of white rice and grain sorghum.
  • Kindfull Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food. Kindfull takes a large chunk of its carbohydrates from peas, brown rice and rice bran. Compared to Kirkland, it also contains an extra source of animal protein from turkey meal. Kindfull also lacks controversial ingredients such as yeast and beet pulp. Despite the differences, both Kirkland and Kindfull adult dog formulations are highly similar.
  • What Dog Food Do Vets Recommend?

    There are as many opinions on the best dog food as dog food brands.

    Some vets say dry commercial kibble is best. Dry dog food takes all the brain work from choosing dog food and makes feeding your dog a well-balanced diet a breeze.

    Others support commercially available canned food, which is often more appealing for picky eaters.

    No matter what type of dog diet you choose, most vets will recommend commercially prepared dog food. It will help you ensure your dog doesn’t get sick because of bad hygiene practices or lack of certain nutrients.

    Wondering how to sieve through the marketing claims and make an informed decision? Here is the best type of dog food recommended by vets.

    Vets recommend choosing dog food that follows the minimum nutritional requirements established by AAFCO. You can find the full guidelines here. Keep in mind that the requirement will differ for dogs at different life stages.

    3 Most Popular Blue Buffalo Dog Food Recipes

    This is the brand’s flagship formula, and one of its most basic. However, its claim to fame is due as much to what’s not inside as to what is.

    This food came along at a time when being corn-, wheat-, and grain-free was enough to set you apart, but nowadays many brands (including Kirkland) have grain-free options.

    The level of protein is as low as in most Kirkland foods, although it does have a bit more fiber (5%). There’s more meat in here, too, as chicken, chicken meal, and chicken fat are all among the primary ingredients.

    You’ll find quite a bit of plant protein in here too, though, and quite a bit of salt. Of course, you’ll also see high-quality foods like kelp, blueberries, and cranberries, so that balances things out a bit.

    All in all, Blue Buffalo’s most basic food is probably slightly better than what you’ll find from Kirkland, but we don’t know if it’s enough to justify the extra cost. Pros

  • Real chicken is first ingredient
  • Early adopter of the grain-free philosophy
  • Includes foods like kelp, cranberries, and raspberries
  • Cons

  • Low in protein
  • Has quite a bit of salt
  • A bit pricey for what you get
  • FAQ

    What brand makes Kirkland dog food?

    Based on the result, Kirkland adult dog food is most comparable to: Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula™ Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe. Diamond Naturals All Life Stages Dog Chicken & Rice Formula. Kindfull Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe Dry Dog Food.

    Is Costco dog food the same as diamond?

    Q: Where are the Kirkland Signature Pet Foods made? A: All of the dry foods are made by Diamond Pet Foods in five company owned manufacturing facilities, all in the United States. Two are located in Arkansas, California, one in Missouri and one in South Carolina.

    What is the healthiest dog food in the world?

    Any food should be able to be fed interchangeably without problems as long as your dog is accustomed to variety (which every dog should be). There’s really not a big difference in quality between Diamond and Kirkland – imo.